Subject: USAID-funded Suharto-ET coffee project!
Date: Fri, 24 Jul 1998 13:53:31 +1100
From: email@example.com (George J. Aditjondro)
Please distribute this to East Timor friends in the US, and especially the Washington Post journalist, Cindy Shiner, who reported the NCBA-USAID project for ET coffee farmers, without reporting its connections with Suharto's eldest daughter! Thanks, GJA
East Timorese coffee robbery:
In the 1970s and 1980s, the export of coffee from East Timor was monopolized by PT Denok, which was backed by General Benny Murdani, the commander of the 1975 East Timor invasion, Operasi Komodo. In the 1990s, after Benny Murdani was desposed from the top position in as ABRI commander, Suharto's eldest daughter, Siti Hardiyanti Rukmana, also known as Tutut, took this monopoly over through her company, PT Citra Inskopindo Persada, based in Dili with a representative office in Jakarta.
This company buys the coffee from the farmers through an Indonesian government imposed network of village cooperatives, Puskud (Pusat Koperasi Unit Desa), grinds 1.2 ton of Arabica coffee per year, and exports it to the US, Australia, and Aotearoa (New Zealand), under the brand name, Cafe Timor .
With the help of a project funded by the U.S. Agency for International Development (US-AID), the National Cooperative Business Association (NCBA) markets the coffee in the US, and also provides technical supervision in East Timor. This has been proudly admitted by Sam Filiaco from the NCBA, in an interview with Cindy Shiner from the Washington Post on Monday, July 20, 1998 (page A14), without any word mentioning Tutut's involvement in this scheme. The funding idea arose after a former U.S. ambassador to Jakarta traveled to East Timor and saw that there was a cartel -- Benny Murdani's PT Denok cartel -- controlling the price of coffee and that therefore the farmers were not receiving a fair price.
Benny Murdani's cartel, however, was simply replaced by a Suharto-protected cartel, since only the company on the top of the pyramid, PT Denok, was replaced by PT Citra Inskopindo Persada, using the same military-backed pseudo-village cooperative network, Puskud (Pusat Kooperasi Unit Desa).
This NCBA-Tutut-Puskud network, which began four years ago with 800 farmers, is now engaging 13,000 of an estimated 30,000 coffee farmers in the occupied territory. As their project coordinators admitted to the Washington Post journalist, their relations with the military are good in the region. No wonder, since the influence of Suharto's son-in-law, Lieutenant General Prabowo Subianto, is still very strong in the region, due to the Suharto family's wealth and the fact that the current East Timorese puppet governor, Jose Abilio Osorio-Soares, is a Prabowo protegee (Aditjondro, 1994: 57-59; Indonesian Manufacturing Directory 1993/1994, pp. 196-197; Jakarta Post , 16 May 1997; Washington Post , July 20, 1998; Cafe Timor packages).
NB: For further information contact office of PT Citra Inskopindo Persada in Jakarta: BBD Plaza, 23-rd Floor, Jalan Imam Bonjol No. 61, Jakarta Pusat. Phone: (62-21) 322 155, 337 102 (5 lines); Fax: (62-21) 328 140, Director: Bungaran Tambunan.
Newcastle, July 22, 1998.
References: Aditjondro, George J. (1994). In the shadow of Mount Ramelau: the impact of the occupation of East Timor. Leiden: INDOC (Indonesian Documentation and Information Centre).
(1995). Bali, Jakarta's colony: social and ecological impacts of Jakarta-based conglomerates in Bali's tourism industry. Working Paper No. 58. Perth: Asia Research Centre, Murdoch University.
(1996). "Suharto family, the Philippines and APEC: the business connections," Philippine News & Features , Vol. XIII, No. 17, December 5.
(1998a), "Suharto & sons: crony capitalism, Suharto style," Washington Post , January 25.
(1998b). Yayasan-yayasan Suharto: cakupan, dampak, dan pertanggungjawabannya" [The Suhartos foundations: their scope, impact, and accountability problem"], published on electronic mail by Kabar dari Pijar (firstname.lastname@example.org; email@example.com) on February 3.
(1998c). The Swiss business links of the Suharto & Habibie oligarchy in Indonesia: a report prepared for the Berne Declaration. Balowski, James (1995). "Indonesian workers strike over wages," Green Left Weekly , July 26. Borsuk, Richard and Jay Solomon (1997). "Bakrie to sell Freeport stakes to Hasan's Nusamba Mineral," The Wall Street Journal Interactive Edition Asia, January 31. Chalmers, Ian M. (1988). Economic nationalism and the Third World state: the political economy of the Indonesian automotive industry, 1950-1984. PhD thesis at the Australian National University (ANU), Canberra, December. Chong, Florence (1996). "Dr Loh's Robina: just another project," Weekend Australian, July 13-14. CISI (1991). A study of top-300 national private business groups in Indonesia, 1991-1992. Jakarta: PT CISI Raya Utama. Cohen, Margot (1996). "Auction Fever: keeping ut with the Sudwikatmonos," The Wall Street Journal , October 3. Datatrust (1986). Reference book on Indonesia's major business groups. First Edition, August 1986. Jakarta: Datatrust Inc. Engardio, Pete and Michael Shari (1996), "The Suharto empire," Business Week , August 19, pp. 14-18. Franklin, Roger (1986). The defender: the story of General Dynamics. New York: Harper & Row. Friedland, Jonathan (1988). "Jakarta's Rockefellers: Bimantara strives to become 'a national asset', Far Eastern Economic Review , November 24, pp. 80-82. Goldstein, Carl (1989). "Complex problems: doubts hang over Indonesia's petrochemical plans," Far Eastern Economic Review , March 30, pp. 52-53. Habir, Manggi (1983). "There's no business like go-go business," Far Eastern Economic Review , April 7, pp. 52-53. -------- and Anthony Rowley (1983). "The extended (corporate) family of Liem Sioe Liong," Far Eastern Economic Review , April 7, pp. 51-54. Halloran, Paul and Mark Hollingsworth (1995). Thatcher's gold: the life & times of Mark Thatcher. London: Simon & Schuster. Harsono, Andreas (1995). "Indonesian labour fury grows," Western Australia, July 31. Haryadi E.F., S. (ed) (1996). Indonesia financial directory 1996-1997. First Edition. Jakarta: PT Admindo Multijaya Promo. IEFR, 1997. Indonesian capital market directory 1997. Jakarta: Institute for Economic and Financial Research (IEFR). Jay, Christopher (1997). Australian expertise in infrastructure. Edgecliff, NSW: Focus Publishing. Jones, Steven (1986). "Suharto's kin linked with plastics monopoly," Asian Wall Street Journal , November 25. -------- and Raphael Pura (1986). "Suharto-linked monopolies hobble economy," Asian Wall Street Journal , November 24. Loveard, Keith (1996). "Suharto's son rises," Asiaweek , April 12, 1996: 34-40. May, Brian (1981). The Indonesian tragedy. Singapore: Graham Brash (Pte) Ltd. McDonald, Hamish (1980). Suharto's Indonesia. Fontana Books. Moore, Robin, Lew Perdue and Nick Rowe (1977). The Washington connection, New York: Condor. Pangaribuan, Robison (1995). The Indonesian State Secretariate 1945-1993. Perth: Asia Research Centre, Murdoch University. Prawoto, Agus (ed) (1995). Direktori asuransi Indonesia 1995. Jakarta: Direktorat Asuransi, Direktorat Jenderal Lembaga Keuangan, Departemen Keuangan. Pura, Raphael (1986). "Suharto family tied to Indonesian oil trade," Asian Wall Street Journal (AWSJ ), November 26. --------(1990a). "Indonesia's Bimantara tries to revamp image," Asian Wall Street Journal , September 17. --------(1990b). "Bimantara maps huge expansion for '90s." Asian Wall Street Journal , September 18. ------- (1993). "Hashim emerges in corporate Indonesia," Asian Wall Street Journal , February 2. Reynolds, Catherine (1997). Draft of Honours thesis at the University of New South Wales in Sydney, Australia. Robison, Richard (1990). Indonesia: the rise of capital. Sydney: Allen & Unwin. Rowley, Anthony (1983). "Indonesia's Liem Investors emerge for the ..... birth of a multinational," Far Eastern Economic Review , April 7, pp. 44-51. Sampson, Anthony (1987). The money lenders: bankers in a dangerous world. Coronet Books, Schwarz, Adam (1989). "Unchartered skies: private interests see profits in Garuda's shake-up." Far Eastern Economic Review , September 21: 71-72. ---------- (1991). "Down to earth: Indonesian satellite service wins few subscribers," Far Eastern Economic Review , June 6, pp. 42-43. ------------ and Jonathan Friedland (1990). "No mere middleman: Suharto's son has high ambitions for Humpuss," Far Eastern Economic Review , August 23: 56-23. ------------ and ------------ (1991). "Indonesia: empire of the son," Far Eastern Economic Review, March 14: 46-53. ------------ and -------------(1992). "Green fingers: Indonesia's Prajogo proves that money grows on trees," Far Eastern Economic Review, March 12, pp. 42-46. Shin, Yoon Hwan (1989). Demystifying the capitalist state: political patronage, bureaucratic interests, and capitalist-in-formation in Soeharto's Indonesia. Ph.D. thesis at Yale University. Smith, Shannon L.D. (1996). Developing Batam: Indonesian political economy under the New Order. Ph.D. thesis at the Australian National University. Soetriyono, Eddy ( 1988). Kisah sukses Liem Sioe Liong. Jakarta: Indomedia. Vriens, Hans (1995). "The grandson also rises," Asia, Inc ., March 1995, pp. 46-51.