|Subject: GLW: East Timor asks for UN-led
Also GLW: Problems 'left behind by UN transition’
From Green Left Weekly, June 21 2006.
East Timor asks for UN-led peacekeeping force
East Timor’s foreign minister Jose Ramos Horta formally requested to a special session of the United Nations Security Council on June 14 that the UN Office In East Timor be extended by at least one month to August 22. The Security Council is expected to discuss within the next few weeks extending this further as well as revising the UN’s mandate and function in East Timor.
UN general-secretary Kofi Annan said a new and upgraded UN presence was needed in East Timor to help restore order in the wake of the political and social crisis of the last month. Annan told the Security Council that the scaling down of the UN in East Timor had happened too quickly and that “The sad events of recent weeks reflect shortcomings not only on the part of the Timorese leadership but also on the part of the international community in inadequately sustaining Timor-Leste’s nation-building process”.
The Timorese government asked the council “to establish immediately a United Nations police force in Timor-Leste, to maintain law and order in Dili and other parts of the country as necessary and re-establish confidence among the people, until the PNTL [East Timor National Police] has undergone reorganisation and restructuring so that it can act as an independent and professional law enforcement agency”. It added that this force should remain for at least a year, including during the presidential and parliamentary elections in 2007.
The East Timorese representative added that while East Timor was deeply indebted to the countries that quickly deployed forces at the government’s request, as the emergency situation was nearing an end it was important that attention now be turned to replacing the current force with a peacekeeping force under the UN umbrella, to reduce political and diplomatic tensions.
The representatives of Portugal and Malaysia supported the Timorese request for a UN-led force, while Australia’s ambassador to the UN, Robert Hill, proposed that the PNTL be led by an Australian, suggesting former Northern Territory and Australian Federal Police commissioner Mick Palmer. He urged that the UN focus on longer term development issues and investigations into recent events, rather than a peacekeeping and security role.
Annan said that it was unlikely that an upgraded UN-led peacekeeping force would be able to take over from the current Australian-led security force for at least six months.
UN special envoy Ian Martin stressed at the council meeting that “there is a pressing need for an impartial investigation of recent events involving loss of life in particular, the disputed number of killings which occurred in Dili on 28-29 April, and the killing by soldiers of unarmed police officers under United Nations escort [and injury to two UN police officers] on 25 May”. He outlined this as the first priority, adding that the UN should play “a major role” in the organisation of the May 2007 elections and that “the review and restoration of the security sector is a crucial task”.
In a June 14 speech to parliament, President Xanana Gusmao told the assembly that the state had become “paralysed” and that “the population is suffering from the consequences”. He added that the failure of the East Timorese state to deal with the crisis had “frighten[ed] all of us who were elected by the people to ensure stability, security and better living conditions” and that it was now “the time to rebuild, rather than to point out blame”. He also stressed that he would be seeking to “continue to fulfil the sacred duty of safeguarding the democratic state” as a “guardian of the constitution”.
The announcement by Gusmao signals an easing of political tensions within the political elite and moves away from a push to use constitutional triggers or other means to dissolve the parliament or replace Prime Minister Mari Alkatiri. Alkatiri and the Fretilin-led government appear to have, for now, weathered allegations in the Australian media that Alkatiri and former interior minister Rogerio Lobato were behind the creation of a special gang to intimidate and eliminate Alkatiri’s opponents.
While overall gang activity in Dili has declined considerably, isolated incidents continue to occur, including some that appear to have a political element, such as threats to and attacks on journalists. Two staff members of the Timor Post were attacked on June 15 and the paper’s editor believes this was due to the paper printing articles critical of the prime minister.
East Timorese and UN-sponsored investigations into the recent violence will be a key test of the credibility and moral authority of the East Timorese political elite following the crisis. International prosectors have arrived in Dili and have started collecting evidence.
The results of these investigations and the resolution of the grievances held by the different rebel factions, within both the army and police, will have a strong influence on the political to-and-fro within the East Timorese elite in the lead-up to the 2007 elections. While Fretilin remains the largest, most consolidated national party, opposition parties and groupings may gain stronger support and new alliances are likely to evolve.
Negotiations with various officers leading the different rebel groups in the East Timorese army and police have progressed, albeit slowly.
As the security situation continues to improve, aid agencies are increasingly concerned with the welfare of the large number of internally displaced people in the camps in and around Dili, estimated at 130,000 around 10% of the entire population of East Timor. A significant proportion of these are children with health problems and poor access to adequate food and aid.
EAST TIMOR: Problems 'left behind by UN transition’
Tomas Freitas is the director of Luta Hamutuk (Fight Together), a research and advocacy institute focusing on economic issues, including East Timor’s Petroleum Fund. The Petroleum Fund is a mechanism to regulate the expenditure of East Timor’s oil and gas proceeds. Freitas was involved in the Timorese clandestine movement against Indonesian occupation and more recently, the campaign for fair maritime boundaries in the Timor Sea. He was interviewed by Green Left Weekly’s Vannessa Hearman.
Freitas told GLW that the proposal to establish an “inquiry” into the violence in East Timor, possibly to be conducted by the United Nations, “is a very good idea”, but that “it won’t resolve the problems of East Timor”.
“The crisis here is not some spontaneous crisis, but is a result of the accumulation of problems left behind by the UN during the transition period [towards independence], especially the decision to change from Falintil [the national liberation army] to setting up the East Timor Defence Force [FDTL].
“The UN Transitional Administration in East Timor should not have overturned Falintil just like that. Falintil should have been allowed to continue to exist for the time being perhaps another 3-5 years and after the veterans of the guerrilla movement have reached pension age, they could be retired from the forces.”
Freitas said that an inquiry would not be sufficient to address perceptions that “not enough has been done for those who gave up their lives for the guerrilla struggle”.
According to Freitas, “kontroladu” (under control) is the term used by East Timor’s leaders to describe the current situation in Dili. “But only during daylight hours. At night time, the situation is still tense, although the people try to entertain themselves by watching the World Cup. Those living on the outskirts are still afraid. Smoke from possibly burning houses can be seen at night. The arson attacks seem to be focused on houses of bureaucrats or members of the government on the edges of Dili.
“Some ministries have started to operate again during the day, but offices of the ministries for agriculture, mineral resources and energy policy and for development have been looted. Computers, desks, chairs, motorbikes and cars have all been destroyed or stolen. Schools and universities are almost totally inactive. Parliamentary sessions started being televised again, as [President] Xanana Gusmao gave his first speech to parliament about the crisis situation.”
Within the FDTL, “Low wages is one complaint, as well as the lack of productive and useful activities”, Freitas said. “In 2005, 300 members of the armed forces left voluntarily. One of them, Julio an old friend of mine had joined Falintil in 1992. He was recruited to the FDTL, but left as he felt he wasn’t doing anything productive. The main activities at the Metinaro Barracks were shooting practice with a small amount of bullets, and lots of waiting around, eating and sleeping. Imagine an ex-guerrilla who used to take on the Indonesian military in the jungle. He couldn’t cope with the boredom.”
Freitas told GLW that most of East Timor’s political parties are saying little about the crisis. “The only ones making public statements are Xanana Gusmao, [Prime Minister] Mari Alkatiri and [foreign minister] Jose Ramos Horta. The NGOs are concentrating on distributing food and water to the refugee camps, while not paying any attention to the substantive political issue that has created the refugees in the first place.”
According to Freitas, it is unclear what solutions are being offered by those political forces pressuring for Alkatiri to resign. “Some are calling for a change to a presidential system, from the current semi-presidential system. Some say that it is better if East Timor becomes part of a federation with Australia or Portugal.
“I think it would be very difficult for them to resolve our problems. It seems what they most want is for Alkatiri and [the ruling party] Fretilin to go. They are concerned that Fretilin would win the 2007 elections again, if they wait until election time. They don’t wish to wait another five years, after the 2007 elections. Some of them are supported by the US and Australia, who would rather the Alkatiri government be gone.
“The US is unhappy with East Timor’s close diplomatic relations with China and Cuba, and the Cuban scholarships given to Timorese medical students. Australia has long had problems with the Timorese government over the oil resources and the issue of whether the pipeline should go to Darwin or Timor.”
From Green Left Weekly, June 21 2006.