Statement on New York
Historical Society's Honoring of Henry Kissinger
The New-York Historical
Society, founded in 1804, occupies an impressive building at
the corner of Central Park West and Richard Gilder Way. A
compliant city recently renamed 77th Street after Gilder,
the Society's executive committee co-chair and major funder
-- a wealthy New York broker, ideologue and founder of the
right-wing think tank, the Manhattan Institute. With this
honor to Henry Kissinger, the N-YHS becomes the overt
instrument of the Manhattan Institute's politics.
Many of the historians protesting the honor to
Kissinger have spent hours and weeks (as we have, starting a half
century ago) in its magnificent library, using its invaluable
archives. But in recent years we have noticed a change in the
Society's mission. A landmark in this change was the 2004 exhibit on
"Alexander Hamilton: The Man Who Made Modern America," which was a
shallow paean to the values of George W. Bush. Now with the honoring
of Henry Kissinger, the cat is fully out of the bag. With this, the
Society throws away 200 years of distinction, sacrificing its
standing, subverting and junking a major historical institution by
politicizing it. While N-YHS has a right to its politics, there's no
doubt that in bestowing this honor on Kissinger those politics are
vile. The trustees of this once-great Society should resign, leaving
Richard Gilder afloat amidst the wreckage that he has created. We
need a new New-York Historical Society.
-- Jesse Lemisch, Professor of History Emeritus,
John Jay College of Criminal Justice, City University of New York
Staughton Lynd, Independent Historian