Subject: Church weighs into abortion debate in Catholic East Timor

Church weighs into abortion debate in Catholic East Timor October 23, 2008  

DILI (AFP) ­ A move to soften tough abortion laws in mainly Catholic East Timor is stirring opposition from the powerful Church.

Activists are backing a proposed law that would loosen the country's blanket ban and allow abortions for women whose lives are in danger.

But church leaders have refused to drop their objections that the bill, scheduled to be voted on by parliament next month, violates basic religious teachings.

"The church is opposing this because they always see abortion as a crime," said Filomena Barros dos Reis from the Alola Foundation women's rights group.

East Timor's current law, which was copied from Indonesia's criminal code during the country's 24-year occupation, bans abortion in all cases.

The new bill contains stiff jail terms of between two and eight years for abortionists and women who get abortions. It would also not allow abortions in the case of rape or incest.

But dos Reis said she has told church leaders that allowing abortions in the case of potentially fatal health complications would save lives.

"We still have a lot of pros and cons because the community of Timor-Leste, they still trust the church... so we are still discussing with the church," she said, using the country's official name.

Justice Minister Lucia Lobato told AFP last week that the proposed law would not significantly liberalise the government's strongly anti-abortion stance.

"The general principle is that abortion is a crime," she said.

"So a mother or a pregnant woman who gets an abortion, consciously or unconsciously, it's still a crime and it has to be processed legally so punishment can be made."

The one exception, she said, was if a doctor certified that the pregnancy was a threat to the mother's life.

This has proven too much for the Catholic Church.

"In principle, the church worldwide doesn't agree with abortion under any conditions because we have the technology to protect mothers, such as transplants," Pastor Martinho Gusmao, from the diocese in the city of Baucau, said in an interview last week.

Impoverished East Timor, which gained independence in 2002 after more than two decades of Indonesian occupation, has the world's highest fertility rate, with the average woman giving birth to eight children, says the United Nations.

Around 98 percent of the population is Catholic and most people remain unaware of birth control despite many church leaders throwing support behind programmes promoting contraception.

President Jose Ramos-Horta recently visited the Vatican and is reportedly eager to sign an agreement known as a "concordata" with the Holy See to formalise East Timor's status as a Catholic country.

The agreement reportedly would guarantee the church certain privileges in terms of its claims to land and property in East Timor, and would strengthen its influence on issues such as abortion.


East Timor says “no” to abortion and proposes an “Accord” with the Catholic Church

Dili (Agenzia Fides) ­ The Church in East Timor has expressed its satisfaction and appreciation for the recent draft bill on the national Penal Code, now awaiting government approval in the next month and a half.
The Code bans abortion, except in extreme cases or particular circumstances in which the mother's health is at risk. Abortion is classified as homicide and violators are prosecuted as criminals.

According to Prime Minister Xanana Gusmao, the new Code is “a step forward for democracy in Timor,” which has had to establish its judicial, educational, and administrative systems from ground zero, following its independence, in the years of the transitional government of the UN.

The new Penal Code, drafted by local experts and internationally-renowned jurists, will substitute the Indonesian Penal Code, which was used in Timor during the occupation, since 1975.

East Timor's President Jose Ramos Horta has also announced that he will ask the Holy See to sign an “Accord,” similar to that of Italy, giving the Catholic religion (professed by 97% of the population) a proper role and public recognition, in administration, schools, and throughout society. The Catholic Church in Timor, which is negotiating on the proposal, would mainly benefit in the area of Church properties and Catholic education, which would be fully recognized and supported by the state.

Back to November Menu
World Leaders Contact List
Main Postings Menu