Imparsial: Statement towards the visit of The
United States of America's President Barack Obama
The visit of The United States of America's President Barack Obama to
Indonesia has received extensive attention from the public and the
Government of Indonesia. His visit is not only important in re-constructing
cooperative relations between the Government of Indonesia and the US
Government, but also important in order to discuss the currently running
process of democratization and human rights enforcement. In that point,
addressing a message, criticisms and suggestions to the Government of
Indonesia and the US, especially in the implementation of the enforcement
agenda of Human Rights is a very necessary thing.
Imparsial assessed that the government of Indonesia has been neglecting
the fulfillment of Human Rights compliance and enforcement, as seen from the
unresolved cases of past Human Rights violations including cases of forced
disappearances and cases of gross Human Rights violations in Aceh and Papua,
which results in the preservation of impunity practice until now.
Democratization process itself requires termination of impunity, which has
been built from the past, by promoting justice, truth, and reconciliation in
Indonesia.
Efforts in preserving impunity are also conducted by the state by not
continuing the discussion of the draft amendment to Law no. 31 year 1997 on
Military Justice. In some cases of Human Rights violations, the Military
Court gave major contributions to the practices of impunity in Indonesia.
For instance, as we all know the current practices of the military court
shows actions such as unfair, dependent, and partial trials in prosecuting
the members of the military who commit crimes, particularly in Human Rights
Crimes, for example the case of Enforce Disappearance of Indonesian
Activists in 1997-1998 in which involving members of Special Forces
(KOPASSUS).
Another thing that should be a matter of concern is the rampant cases of
violence against Human Rights defenders. Even the Munir murder case until
now has not yet completed its disclosure. This condition is contrary to
President Susilo Bambang Yudhoyono's statement when he was inaugurated as
President in 2004, where he stated that the disclosure of Munir's case is a
test of history which must be completed.
Another issue that is no less important is the lack of respect for the
human rights situation in Papua, which is increasingly worrying. Effort to
reduce conflict, such as by dialogue, was not put as a major choice by the
Government. The Government's favors, however, more to the option on security
approach. Issues such as the right to life and freedom of expression,
violations of economic, social and culture rights, which emerges since the
new order period, did not taught the government to improve the conditions in
Papua.
In addition, the practice of human rights abuses in other areas still
continues. Military violence occurred in Pasuruan, and excessive police
violence also happens in South Sumatera and South Sulawesi, also in several
other areas. This act of violence which was committed by State officials,
especially security forces, is not separate from the unfinished process of
security sector reform in Indonesia.
Another issue regarding the incoherent reform of the security sector
causes the emergence of instability between security assurance and freedom.
This can be seen from the government's policy in the response to criminal
acts of terrorism in Indonesia. Although due to this policy the government
received positive acknowledgements from the international world, which was
then accompanied by the provision of a large sum of financial aid, but this
counter-terrorism policy contains a broad impact in regard to its respect
towards Human Rights in Indonesia. By prioritizing a counter-terror policy
which emphasizes excessive abilities recurrently ignores the respect towards
the values of law and human rights, hence resulted violations of the
presumption of innocence, which led to cases of arbitrary arrest, torture,
wrongfully accused arrests, stigmatization, criminalization, and so on and
so forth.
The guarantee to the freedom of religion and freedom of thought and
expression is not enough to gain a strong assurance from the government,
although it was already recognized by the constitution. An example of this
weak assurance is seen through cases of violence against the Ahmadiyya group
and also the banning of books regarding Ahmadiyya.
Based on the previously mentioned cases, Imparsial stated that it is wise
if President Barack Obama, as a support of efforts to democratization and
respect towards Human Rights in Indonesia, can express as well as discuss
the issues mentioned above to the Government of Indonesia. The problematic
cases which has not received its acknowledgement and disclosure from the
Indonesian Government are for instance the impunity towards the perpetrators
of heavy Human Rights violations, is expected to be a point of consideration
for President Obama's visit to Indonesia.
In regard to Indonesia's support in the effort to strengthen
democratization and Human Rights in the United States of America, we also
urged the acceleration act to close down Guantanamo Prison, and a fair trial
and justice for terrorism suspects whom are currently detained at
Guantanamo.
We also urge the Government of Indonesia as well as the United States to
immediately ratify the Rome Statute, because neither of the two state
governments had done so.
Thus, the visit of President Obama to Indonesia will not only able to
receive numerous greetings from the people of Indonesia, but also provides a
positive record in the promotion and enforcement of Human Rights in
Indonesia and the United States.
Jakarta, March 11, 2010
Poengky Indarti
Managing Director
Ph: +6281315696308
E-mail: poengky@imparsial.org
12 March 2010
Sumber Pers_Release : Imparsial's Press Release
No. 005/Press Release/IMP/III/2010
see also